Artificial intelligence is generating a lot of interest in the healthcare field, with many hospitals and health systems already adopting the technology, often with great administrative success.
However, for AI to be successful in healthcare, especially in the clinical arena, it must address growing concerns about model transparency and explainability.
In a world where decisions mean life or death, understanding and trusting AI decisions is not just a technical need. It is an ethical imperative.
Neeraj Mainkar is vice president of software engineering and advanced technology at Proprio, a company that develops immersive tools for surgeons, and has extensive expertise in the application of algorithms in healthcare. Healthcare IT News spoke with him about explainability, patient safety and trust, error identification, regulatory compliance, and the need for ethical standards in AI.
Q. What does explainability mean in the field of artificial intelligence?
A. Explainability refers to the ability of an AI model to understand and clearly explain how it arrived at a particular decision. With simpler AI models, such as decision trees, this process is relatively easy, as the decision path is easily traced and interpreted.
But when we move into the realm of complex deep learning models, consisting of many layers and complex neural networks, understanding the decision-making process becomes much more difficult.
Deep learning models operate with a huge number of parameters and complex architectures, making it nearly impossible to directly trace their decision paths. Reverse engineering these models or investigating specific issues in their code can be extremely difficult.
When predictions do not match expectations, the exact reasons for this discrepancy can be difficult to pinpoint due to the complexity of the models. Due to a lack of transparency, even the creators of these models can have difficulty fully explaining their behavior and outputs.
Opacity Complex AI systems pose significant challenges, especially in areas such as healthcare, where understanding the rationale behind decisions is critical. As AI becomes more deeply ingrained in our lives, there is a growing demand for explainable AI. Explainable AI aims to make AI models more interpretable and transparent, making the decision-making process understandable and trustworthy.
Q. What are the technical and ethical implications of AI explainability?
A. The pursuit of explainability has both technical and ethical implications to consider: On the technical side, simplifying a model to increase explainability may reduce performance, but a clear understanding of the origins of outputs can also help AI engineers debug and improve their algorithms.
Ethically, explainability helps identify bias in AI models, promote fairness of treatment, and eliminate discrimination against under-represented small groups. Explainable AI also allows end users to understand how decisions are being made while protecting sensitive information in compliance with HIPAA.
Q. Explain error identification as it relates to explainability.
A. Explainability is a key component of effectively identifying and correcting errors in AI systems. The ability to understand and interpret how an AI model arrived at a decision or output is necessary to effectively identify and correct errors.
By tracing the decision path, you can pinpoint where the model went wrong and understand the “why” behind the incorrect predictions. This understanding is crucial for making necessary adjustments to improve the model.
Continuous improvement of AI models Much depends on understanding failure: In healthcare, where patient safety is paramount, the ability to quickly and accurately debug and refine models is essential.
Q. Can you please elaborate on regulatory compliance regarding explainability?
A. Healthcare is a highly regulated industry and AI systems must meet strict standards and guidelines to ensure safety, effectiveness, and ethical use. Explainability is key to achieving compliance as it addresses several key requirements:
- Transparency. Explainability makes every decision made by an AI reversible and understandable. This transparency is necessary to maintain trust and ensure that AI systems operate within ethical and legal bounds.
- verification. Explainable AI allows you to demonstrate that your models have been thoroughly tested and validated to work as intended across a range of scenarios.
- Mitigating bias. Explainability helps identify and mitigate biased decision-making patterns, ensuring that models do not unfairly disadvantage certain groups.
As AI continues to evolve, a focus on explainability will remain a key aspect of regulatory frameworks to ensure these advanced technologies are used responsibly and effectively in healthcare.
Q. Where do ethical standards come into play when it comes to explainability?
A. Ethical standards play a critical role in the responsible development and deployment of AI systems, especially in sensitive and high-risk domains such as healthcare. Explainability is intrinsically tied to these ethical standards, ensuring that AI systems operate transparently, fairly, and responsibly, in line with the core ethical principles of healthcare.
Responsible AI It means operating within ethical boundaries. Promoting a high degree of explainability in AI promotes trust and credibility, ensuring AI decisions are transparent, justifiable, and ultimately beneficial to patient care. Ethical standards guide responsible disclosure, protecting user privacy, complying with regulatory requirements such as HIPAA, and promoting public trust in AI systems.
Follow Bill’s HIT articles on LinkedIn: Bill Siwicki
Email: bsiwicki@himss.org
Healthcare IT News is a publication of HIMSS Media.